Friday, October 23rd
6pm–9pm
This Halloween, step inside a haunted tavern for an unforgettable night of murder, mystery, dinner, and laughs!
Sherlock Holmes and the Case of the Tavern Spirit is a spooky comedy mystery set in a creaky old tavern where a mischievous ghost is rattling cutlery, startling guests, and sending customers running for the door.
Under flickering gaslight and jack-o’-lantern glow, Sherlock Holmes arrives to uncover the truth. Is the haunting the work of a jealous rival, a mysterious medium, or something truly supernatural?
Enjoy clever clues, hilarious scares, witty banter, audience interaction, and a surprise finale as the mystery unfolds throughout the evening.
Eat. Drink. Laugh. Solve the mystery.
Reserve your seats now before the bell tolls midnight—and find out whether the only spirits haunting the tavern are the ones being poured at the bar!
Doors open for seating and bar service begins at 6pm
Show and Dinner service begins 7pm
**times may vary depending on actors and audience participation**
Blue Arrow Farm
86 Glenwood Rd
Pine Island, NY
Tickets Include:
Three-course buffet style dinner
Water and coffee included
Bar drinks available for purchase
Buffet Dinner Menu:
Chef's choice hand passed appetizers
Seasonal salad with balsamic vinaigrette
Chicken parmesan
Penne vodka (gluten free)
Mixed vegetables
Mashed red potatoes
Roast beef carving station
Chocolate-covered cheesecake
Tiramisu
**buffet is not unlimited**
Frequently Asked Questions
- What is a high top floor and how far back is it? Is it on a different level than the main floor? Is the view obstructed by anything? Our main floor seating has the best views of the stage. Our high top floor is raised a few feet above the main floor and has some minor obstructed views.
- Is there a stage or do the performers interact in the audience? There is a full sized professional stage that is raised from the floor. The performers will interact with the audience on and off the stage and within the table seating areas.
- Are the tables reserved or is it a first come first serve basis? Tables are assigned based on a first come, first served basis as well as the table size needed to accommodate the size of the party.
- How many people can sit at a table? Our tables seat 2, 4, and 6 guests. Your table size will be assigned depending on the size of your party.
- If I purchase 4 tickets and at the last minute someone wants to join us, can they? Yes, please text us at (845) 533‑3351 with any updates needed for your reservations.
- How much is the money-back Purchase Protection? Purchase Protection cost is per ticket — Once you select your desired quantity, the cost will be visible in the Purchase Protection section.
